5. This Creepy “You Are My Sunshine” Cover

OK, maybe this cover by Frank Iero And The Patience is not that creepy, but can you picture it in a scene from a horror movie where a kid is waiting for the monster to appear? Yes, you can. In Frank’s words, listening to the whole song was a new experience for him. “A lot of us grew up singing the chorus as kids but never knowing what extreme sorrow the song was about,” he shared. Frank’s voice really conveys strong emotions in this one, and you can’t help but listen to it on repeat.